Overrated does not mean bad. Nearly every book here has a real idea in it. What earned it a place is the gap between its reputation and what you actually get for the hours — usually one good chapter, restated.
Three patterns account for most of the list. Books whose central research has not held up. Books whose examples have aged badly enough to undermine the argument. And books that would have been an excellent long essay and were stretched to fill a spine.
We have said what the useful part of each one is, so you can take it without reading the rest. That is a more honest service than pretending the famous book has nothing in it, and more useful than pretending it deserves the pedestal.